Injuryboard Commentary - Accidents

NTSB Recognizes Need to Better Monitor Truck Driver Fatigue

Michael Phelan — Fri, 04 Dec 2009 01:00:00 GMT

Last month, Deborah Hersman , Chairwoman of the National Transportation Safety Board, spoke in Washington to the National Press Club and stated that every day over 100 Americans die in transportation accidents, mostly on our highways. After her speech, the Chairwoman turned her comments to truck accident prevention.

Chairwoma Hersman recognized driver fatigue as a major cause of truck crashes and called for Electronic Onboard Recorders (EOBRs) on all commercial trucks. Her rationale for this safety device is that NTSB "investigate accidents on a regular basis where we find two sets of log books [with one being false]." In other words, even the NTSB recognizes that fudging driver log books is a common practice to enable drivers to be on duty for more hours than is legally permitted. While not fool proof, EOBRs are harder to fudge than paper driver logs. Monitoring driver fatigue is an important safety issue.

As I discussed in a recent blog, none of these monitoring devices are of any use in civil litigation unless the evidence is preserved. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations permit trucking companies to destroy this evidence six months after the crash. That's why truck accident vicitims should consult an experienced truck accident lawyer as soon as possible. The first thing the lawyer should do is send a letter to the truck company and its insurance carrier demanding that all evidence from the truck and the scene be preserved.

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Michael Phelan

As HRT Grows, Responsibilities for Protecting Public Also Increase

John Cooper — Thu, 03 Dec 2009 09:15:48 GMT

HRT, which operates public transportation throughout Tidewater, had a big year in 2009. Hampton Roads Transit broke ground on The Tide light rail system in Norfolk, revised its bus routes repeatedly, expanded ferry services across the Elizabeth River and entered into preliminary planning discussions with city officials to bring light rail to Virginia Beach and Chesapeake.

The semi-private agency--it draws about 80 percent of its operating funds from federal, state and local governments--also just announced plans to move into a new headquarters complex in the heart of downtown Norfolk.

I have written before that providing comprehensive and state-of-the-art transit options is essential for the Seven Cities of Chesapeake, Hampton, Newport News, Norfolk, Portsmouth, Suffolk, and Virginia Beach. Every HRT or WAVE bus passenger, every ferry rider, and each future Tide commuter represents one driver not on some portion of Hampton Roads' dangerous and frustratingly overcrowded highways, bridges, tunnels and surface roads.

But mass transit is not without its own problems. Long considered a model of commuter rail safety, the Washington, D.C., Metro system has seen multiple deadly accidents this year. City bus crashes involving cars, bicyclists and pedestrians occur with alarming frequency. While the United States has, thankfully, gone some time without a truly tragic ferry accident, last week's capsizing in Bangladesh provided a shocking reminder of how quickly situations can turn deadly on even calm waters.

As HRT expands its network, then, it also needs to expand its focus on protecting passengers, operators and everyone else who shares Tidewater's roads and waterways. The transit agency has a strong safety record, but the chances for things to go wrong will grow in direct proportion to the growth of HRt's fleet and ridership.

As quasi-public entities, transit authorities like HRT often get the government's immunity from lawsuit or special limitations on liability for injuries they cause. I, as an accident attorney in Hampton Roads, VA, have made claims against HRT for injured bus passengers, however. These claims are allowed and treated just as any insurance case involving a traffic accident or improper operation of a vehicle. The duty of common carriers to protect riders' for safety are generally high.

I do hope, as a Norfolk resident, that HRT will increase its efforts on safety as its responsibilities increase and also that the agency keeps high insurance coverage so it is readyto deal with any tragic disaster that may occur. As a lawyer who represents folks hurt in mass transit and railroad crossing accidents, I know that the risks of death or serious injury are always present when trains and buses are mixed on busy roads with cars and pedestrians.

About the Editors: The Shapiro, Cooper, Lewis & Appleton personal injury law firm, whose attorneys work out of offices in Virginia (VA) and North Carolina (NC), edits the injury law blogs Virginia Beach Injuryboard, Norfolk Injuryboard, and Northeast North Carolina Injuryboard as pro bono services.

EJL

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by John Cooper

Two Single Car Accidents Remind Us That Winter Driving Requires Extra Care

Mike Bryant — Wed, 02 Dec 2009 09:47:00 GMT

Wednesday night, two separate collisions in northern Todd County were reported. Todd County Sheriff personal believe that snow played a role in both incidents.:

Around 7 am a eastbound pickup on Todd County Road 73 west of Hewitt lost control 73 and rolled.
An hour later, a southbound 2003 Chevrolet Cavalier on Todd County Road 23 near Hewitt went out of control, went into the ditch and rolled.

This is exactly the type of accident, I blogged about with: Single Car Accidents: Is There A Claim? . Hopefully, all of those involved will recover quickly, but if not the help of experienced Personal Injury attorneys can make a difference in getting to the bottom of what coverages are involved.

Despite the warm November it won't be long until we see winter conditions across the state. For all Drivers winter road tips from DPS and MnDOT include:

Always use seat belts.
Accelerate and decelerate slowly on icy/snow-covered roads to retain traction and avoid skids.
Do not use cruise control.
Do not “power up” hills, which may cause wheels to spin. Build momentum before reaching a hill and don’t stop while traveling uphill. Reduce speed before going downhill.
Know your brakes. Keep the heel of your foot on the floor and use the ball of the foot to apply firm, steady pressure on the brake pedal.
Give yourself plenty of travel time. Don’t put your schedule before safety.
Clear snow and ice from vehicle windows, hood, headlights, brake lights and directional signals.
Headlights must be turned on when it is snowing or sleeting.

Most police officers asked say the key is usually to Just Slow Down.

Sgt. Jeff Wenker of the Marshall Police Department made a number of great suggestions concerning winter driving. They included:

Watch the weather, don't travel if the weather is bad
Carry extra clothing, extra blankets and extra food with you and a heat source such as Sterno or candles is not a bad idea to take along.
An empty can, such as a coffee can, can be used for bathroom breaks. Toilet paper and hand wipes could be useful, as well.
If you are on medications, always carry extra.
Don't store extra water in your vehicle because it will freeze, but take extra water with you before you leave on the trip.
Make sure your cell phone is fully charged and bring a charger with you.
Let someone know the route you will be taking and do not deviate from it.
Take your time. A four-hour trip might take five. It's easier to drive slow when you've allowed the time.
If you do slide off the road or have to pull over due to the weather or road conditions: Your car can be an effective shelter so don't leave it unless you have to. Windchills are dangerous and can kill if you are exposed for too long. A vehicle offers some protection from that.
If it's a white-out, you don't want to walk out, because you can lose your way.
Run the engine 10 minutes every hour to help keep you warm. Bundle up in the extra clothes and blankets.
Keep the windows open a crack so you stand less chance of being poisoned by carbon monoxide. Check the tail pipe periodically and clear it if necessary to keep the exhaust from coming back into the vehicle.

Hopefully, all of the suggestions will lead to lives being saved and people making it home safe this winter.

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Mike Bryant

An Iowa train vs car wreck is such A Painful Case

Steve Lombardi — Tue, 01 Dec 2009 12:01:00 GMT

Join me this afternoon for a walk with James Joyce. This is to honor all of those people who die from collisions with trains at train-road-crossings in Iowa and around the nation. In some ways they are preventable but in other ways not so easily prevented. A Painful Case is a short story raising speculation of whether drink, depression or just distraction caused the woman to be out walking across the rails. It's really a wonderful story filled with raw emotions that undulate as if we are on a roller coaster ride at Rocky Point.

This is not unlike the emotions you will go through when trying a case. As prepared as you think you are, you will find out just how difficult it is to control your emotions as the trial unfolds. You do not control the trial so much as IT controls you. As one of my mentors said in response to my comments about my adrenaline level, "Steve in trial work you will experience the highest highs and the lowest lows. Learn not to get too excited about your wins or your losses." Mr. Dutton couldn't have been more accurate. So join James Joyce as he explores Dublin with Mr. James Duffey's not-so-simple life in Ireland, a trial of sorts.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RYukNEZrzdU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAgD3Ve0r8A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31jpicjjVzA

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Steve Lombardi

Increased safety needed for DC Metro Subway, train and bus drivers

Doug Landau — Sun, 29 Nov 2009 22:48:00 GMT

After four metro drivers have been injured in train accidents since June, it appears that greater safety training is needed by DC Metro. Union officials have also called for more safety training for new and existing subway train operators. Having tried cases where the employer tries to rely on the injured workers' signatures on a safety book, DC workplace accident lawyer Doug Landau knows firsthand that there must be actual, "hands on" safety training, and that such safety training must continue throughout a train, bus or Metro driver's career. Personal injury lawyer Landau notes that the National Transportation Safety Board is investigating the spate of accidents on the DC Metrorail system. Because these "common carriers" are subject to special rules and responsibilities when passengers are injured, the ABRAMS LANDAU trial attorney calls upon the District of Columbia Government to step up its safety training and accident prevention procedures.

A subway, train, railroad, ferry, bus and shuttle service are all generally Common Carriers. They convey passengers without refusal if the approved fare or charge is paid. The second definition in the Blacks Law Dictionary goes on to state that a Common carrier is “One who holds himself out the public as engaged in business of transportation of persons or property from place to place for compensation, and who offers services to the general public.” If you or someone you know has been injured in a Metro train, bus or subway car crash, e-mail us at ABRAMS LANDAU, Ltd., or call 703-796-9555 today.

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Doug Landau

Drunk Driver Hit's Patrol Car

Mike Bryant — Sat, 28 Nov 2009 23:00:00 GMT

Thanksgiving morning, State Trooper Sam Catlin was making a drunk driving stop along Highway 52 near Rochester. A speeding car being driven by a Rochester woman hit his sitting patrol car. The driver was cited for 3rd degree DWI and authorities say more charges could follow.

These are officers who are on the roads doing their jobs. Protecting society and doing their work in full uniform with lights going. I have had the honor on a number of occasions to represent some of Minnesota's finest. Usually, they are hit by cars going too fast and not giving them the room they need.

Minnesota law requires all cars to move over one lane when emergency vehicles are on the road. It's pretty simple to keep those actions in mind. While the law doesn't directly require a reduction in speed , it's the safe thing to do and it is taking into consideration the conditions at the time.

If it's wintry weather and the emergency vehicles are dealing with a car in the ditch, consider for a minute how the car got there. It's probably a case of the road itself being especially slippery in the very same area. A couple of times a year, we will be involved in layered car accidents where one car hits another and within the next ten minutes, two or three more impacts take place. A good look out and slowing down will make a difference. Also if you are in an accident, make sure you clear yourself and all passengers away from the dangers of oncoming cars.

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Mike Bryant

Was It Alcohol? A Deer? Or Both That Caused SUV Rollover?

Mike Bryant — Sat, 28 Nov 2009 21:12:59 GMT

Wednesday night, a SUV rolled after leaving northbound Hwy. 169, north of Garrison. The driver and a passenger where injured. The driver told the State Patrol that a deer caused the incident. Initial reports are that alcohol was detected on the driver. The passenger was taken to the St Cloud Hospital.

While there is no liability claim for the driver of the car, passengers may still have a claim for liability depending on the facts of the collision. It is important that these case be investigated early by an Attorney who does this type of work. Hopefully, both of these people will heal up quickly.

The Minnesota Department of Traffic Safety's "Crash Facts 2007" indicated that there were 3,144 vehicle-deer accidents reported last year with 336 injuries and six fatalities.

The Duluth News Tribune recently published some helpful suggestions:

Rule 1: Treat every deer as if it’s going to cross in front of you. If you assume a deer feeding on the shoulder is going to hold its position until you have gone by, you’re just an accident waiting to happen.

Rule 2: Drive according to the conditions. If the night is foggy, rainy, or slippery, you might not be able to prevent a collision, but you can minimize the damage if you’re driving slowly enough. Don’t just speed along and hope nothing gets in your way.

Rule 3: Keep your eyes on the road at all times. You may only have a second or two to react to a deer crossing the highway. If you’re not an attentive driver, you can get hurt.

Questions as to what happened in this case will need to be answered.

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Mike Bryant

Oklahoma Commercial Trucking Accident Kills

Christy Thompson — Fri, 27 Nov 2009 17:42:39 GMT

A collision in Lincoln County, Oklahoma was the cause of Johnny Leemaster's death. It happens far too frequently and more so now than just about ever in US roadway history. Leemaster was operating a vehicle headed north down U.S. 177 while Justin Colley headed south down 177.

The fatal accident occurred when Colley attempted to pass a slow-moving commercial trucker ahead of him. In so doing, he collided with Leemaster. Both driver's attempted to swerve out of the other's way, but in the end, Leemaster ended paying with his life because a commercial trucker was unwilling to pull over to let faster moving vehicles pass.

An important detail of this story that should be strongly considered: state troopers noted there was a rolling fog during the time of the collision. As a commercial trucker with a specialized license, the operator of the rig assuredly knew better -- anyone who operates with a Class C license or higher is educated well enough about fog to know that even the most well lit vehicles are scarcely visible in a rolling fog.

Colley, who collided with Leemaster but lived, was every bit within his rights as a motorist to pass the commercial trucker. As motorists, we all have the legal right to pass a vehicle moving at a speed below the speed limit or far slower than the flow of traffic on an interstate roadway.

As a complete aside, whether Colley and other drivers had been behind the trucker or not, given the size of his load and rig, and the abhorrent weather conditions, this trucker was grossly irresponsible not to have pulled aside and to have waited for conditions to improve.

So the question is, why are there not more and better regulations in the commercial trucking industry? Because the road is a trucker's office; when he isn't moving, he isn't getting paid. Fatalities such as that of Leemaster, who probably just wanted to get home, and victims like Colley, the motorist who killed Leemaster because of the negligence of the trucker, should be taken so much more seriously than they are. Regulations that place a higher value on human life than monetary profit are way past due in the trucking business.

Accidents involving commercial vehicles grow in numbers every year. It's high time for some preventative measures and new, stricter regulation from within the trucking industry. A severe penalty for truckers driving in bad weather or not pulling over when unable to keep up with the flow of traffic may have saved Leemaster's life.

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Christy Thompson

I-35 Texas Car Accident Involves a Cyclone and a Hawkeye Football Player

Steve Lombardi — Thu, 26 Nov 2009 10:33:13 GMT

David Cato, 19 who plays defensive back for the Iowa Hawkeyes and Ter’ran Denton, (sic) 19 a defensive back from the Iowa State Cyclones were driving on I-35 south of Purcell at 10:00 a.m. on a Sunday when the car they were in rolled after coming in contact with a semi-truck. According to the news report the trooper has the 18-wheeler being nudged before rolling and striking the embankment on the west side of the Interstate Highway.

Both Cato and Denton were wearing seatbelts. Both required medical care and treatment. It appears the most seriously injured was Denton, the Iowa State Cyclone, who was transported to the Norman Regional Hospital for a head injury. There is no indication if he suffered from traumatic brain injury or how serious and extensive his head injury.

David Cato is listed on the Iowa Hawkeye Football team roster as a sophomore defensive back from Arlington, Texas. He is listed as second on the depth chart behind Sash.

David Cato

So.

5-11/205

Arlington, TX (Summit)

Ter’ran Benton is listed on the Cyclones roster as also from Arlington, Texas and a defensive back in his sophomore year. The roster has his last name as Benton not Denton.

Benton, Ter'ran

6-0

197

So.

Arlington, Texas (Summit)

Read Lombardi on The Verdict.

Hawkeye Cato and Cyclone Benton involved in I-35 Collision in Texas...
Posted on 11/26/2009

I-35 Texas Car Accident Involves a Cyclone and a Hawkeye Football Player

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Steve Lombardi

Seat Belt Enforcement a Priority for Virginia (VA) State Police This Thanksgiving

Jim Lewis — Thu, 26 Nov 2009 09:05:00 GMT

Seventy-five Virginia (VA) State Police officers will be patrolling the commonwealth's highways this Thanksgiving. Near the top of the list they will have for stopping motorists traveling to and from holiday meals, Black Friday sales and is failing to wear seat belts.

Statistics released to Virginia newspapers on Nov. 24 indicate that 12 motorists died in accidents on Virginia roads during Thanksgiving 2008. Nine of those people were not wearing seat belts.

Virginia's seat belt laws cover drivers and all front-seat passengers. Also, children younger than seven years of age must be properly restrained in age- and size-appropriate child safety seats in the back seat of a moving car, truck or van.

Locally, the Daily Press is reporting the Newport News police will be out in force between Wednesday and Monday and also that AAA is projecting that 970,000 cars will hit the road throughout Virginia this long weekend.

Drive safe, buckle up and have a happy and healthy Thanksgiving!

EJL

Originally posted at InjuryBoard by Jim Lewis